The classic rework scene: budget approved, hardware delivered, brackets drilled and mounted — power on, and the basement devices can't connect, the glass-curtain building drops packets all day. Taking it down and remounting doubles the labor cost and halves customer confidence.

With RF, "find out after installation" usually means too late. A site survey is the only step that converts "it should work" into "it measurably works" before construction begins. This article covers how to do one properly: calculate first, then measure, then decide placement. Antenna selection was issue 26; post-installation troubleshooting was issue 28 — this one covers the decision in between that decides everything: where to put it.

1. Calculate first: the paper link budget

Walk the numbers on paper before anything goes on a roof. LoRa's link budget is generous (typically around 155 dB), but indoor losses deduct quickly. The arithmetic:

Available margin = link budget − path loss − Σ penetration losses − installation margin

Estimate path loss with the free-space formula (add 6 dB per doubling of distance; indoors, redo the estimate with a propagation exponent around 4); sum penetration losses wall by wall using the table below; the installation margin covers weather, humidity, foot traffic, and device reorientation. The hard rule: any location with less than 10 dB remaining is treated as unreliable — not "might fail," but "will fail, we just don't know when."

A common example: a terminal on the third-floor office, gateway candidate in the first-floor telecom room. Three concrete floor slabs (25 dB each) plus two brick walls (12 dB each) puts penetration above 100 dB — the proposal dies on paper. No site visit needed to test "maybe it works."

2. The cheat sheet: how much each wall costs

Additional losses by material (near 868 MHz, cross-referenced field values; expect ±5 dB per building):

Obstacle Additional loss Notes
Drywall / light partitions 3–6 dB Minor
Brick wall (24 cm) 10–15 dB Most common
Reinforced concrete wall (20 cm) 18–25 dB Load-bearing, heavy loss
Concrete floor slab 25–30 dB The cross-floor killer
Metal doors / racking 25–35 dB Effectively shielding
Coated glass (Low-E curtain wall) 20–30 dB Most overlooked
Human body (close range) 8–12 dB Mandatory for wearables

The most valuable word in this table is "coated." Curtain-wall glass in modern office buildings carries a metallic thermal coating — to RF it is effectively a metal mesh. The building looks transparent; the signal doesn't get in. Asking the facility manager one question — "is the glass Low-E?" — saves ten site visits.

The same logic applies vertically: budget cross-floor links at 25 dB per slab, minimum. From basement level one to the third floor, five slabs — out on paper. The answer to deep indoor coverage is never "a more powerful gateway." It is more gateways, each penetrating fewer walls.

3. Then measure: the five-step survey

The paper pass only eliminates obviously unfeasible designs; final placement comes from measurement. Five steps:

Step one: desk survey. Satellite imagery for the building layout; mark candidate locations; confirm three things with the facility manager — power availability, backhaul conditions (how far the Ethernet runs, what the 4G signal looks like), and access rights to rooftops and telecom rooms. A location without power and backhaul scores zero no matter how good the RF is.

Step two: temporary mounting. Set up a gateway at each candidate location on a pole or tripod, as close as possible to the final mounting height — the antenna issue's conclusion still holds: height beats gain. Raising the same gateway two meters routinely outperforms an antenna ten times the price.

Step three: the walk test. Carry an off-the-shelf terminal (a standard temperature or battery-reporting node works) along the planned device locations, pausing at representative points to log RSSI and SNR. The platform's real-time data page does the recording: every uplink shows the received signal quality at the gateway side; photograph each point and the survey data has provenance.

Step four: interpreting the numbers. Three thresholds: RSSI below −120 dBm is the warning zone; SNR approaching the demodulation limits at low data rates (−20 dB at SF11, −7.5 dB at SF12) means one fade from packet loss; and check uplink and downlink separately — a working uplink does not guarantee a working downlink, because gateway downlink power is regulator-capped (14 dBm EIRP on EU868 downlink). Many "uplink full bars, downlink lost" projects die on exactly that line. Confirm ADR convergence at every point during the walk test; do not stop at first join.

Step five: the report. Placement decision, per-point RSSI/SNR records, photos, and the paper budget, assembled into one survey report. Recommend attaching it to the contract — later coverage disputes get settled with data, not with recollections of "someone said three kilometers."

4. Five placement principles

Once measurements are in, converge the decision with five rules:

  1. Height first. Under equal conditions, raising the mounting position is always the cheapest performance gain;
  2. Planar center. Place the gateway near the geometric center of the coverage area so the farthest terminals penetrate fewer walls;
  3. Avoid metal and coatings. Face the antenna toward open space; a metal wall behind it halves the coverage;
  4. Power and backhaul before RF. A location that passes the radio test but can't get power or a cable is out — surveys most often get this priority backwards;
  5. Leave a maintenance path. The person swapping the gateway in three years is not the person climbing today.

5. Three common misjudgments

Misjudgment one: good RSSI means a good network. Issue 28 documented the real case: RF survey green across the board, random packet loss six months after launch. RSSI is only physical-layer reception strength. ADR state, downlink windows, and ACK retransmissions are protocol-layer indicators — read them during the walk test, not after go-live.

Misjudgment two: one test represents the whole year. Seasonal vegetation (outdoors), HVAC ducting and occupancy density (indoors), and device reorientation all consume margin at the 5 dB level. That is why the paper budget keeps a 10 dB hard line — one sunny walk test cannot measure the rainy season.

Misjudgment three: budgeting with "maximum range." The vendor's fifteen kilometers is open-field line-of-sight at the lowest data rate. Urban coverage is typically estimated within a kilometer or two; indoor coverage is estimated in walls, not meters. The budgeting unit should be "margin at the worst point" from day one, never "average distance."

Closing

A survey costs little — one gateway, one terminal, half a day of labor. Rework costs a lot — disassembly, downtime, and customer trust. Three things worth taking away: the 10 dB margin hard line, the Low-E glass question, and testing uplink and downlink separately.


This is issue 36 of the LoRaWAN series. Antenna gain and mounting: issue 26. Protocol-layer troubleshooting: issue 28. Link budget and physical-layer parameters: the dedicated LoRa PHY article. Penetration-loss figures are cross-referenced field values; verify against an actual walk test per building. This article involves no USD amounts and no currency conversion.